Fede­ral Car­tel Office impo­ses fines against an alu­mi­num cartel

At the end of last year, Ger­many’s Fede­ral Car­tel Office impo­sed fines in the amount of EUR 175 mil­li­on against five alu­mi­num for­ging com­pa­nies and ten employees of the affec­ted com­pa­nies (Noti­ce of the Fede­ral Car­tel Office of 23 Decem­ber 2020) based on anti-competitive arran­ge­ments (“car­tel”) which had exis­ted for years.

Arran­ge­ment of cos­ts and rebates

Accor­ding to the Fede­ral Car­tel Office, repre­sen­ta­ti­ves from the par­ti­ci­pa­ting com­pa­nies met a total of 23 times bet­ween the years 2006 and 2018 and exch­an­ged infor­ma­ti­on about cos­ts and reba­tes within the frame­work of the so-called “Alu­mi­num For­ging Group.”

In the cour­se of the­se mee­tings, accor­ding to state­ments made by the Fede­ral Car­tel Office, a basic under­stan­ding was rea­ched among the par­ti­ci­pan­ts as to how pro­cu­re­ment cos­ts and cost increa­ses would be pas­sed on to cus­to­mers. To this end, the par­ti­ci­pan­ts exch­an­ged infor­ma­ti­on about indi­vi­du­al purcha­sing cos­ts and reba­tes, as well as dis­cus­sing pos­si­ble forms in which reba­tes could be offe­red to cus­to­mers and how suc­cessful tho­se reba­tes were.

Inves­ti­ga­ti­on trig­ge­red by a leni­en­cy application

The Fede­ral Car­tel Office­’s inves­ti­ga­ti­on was trig­ge­red by infor­ma­ti­on pro­vi­ded by one of the par­ti­ci­pan­ts in the car­tel. This com­pa­ny took advan­ta­ge of the “leni­en­cy” pro­gram (§ 33e of the Act against Res­traints on Com­pe­ti­ti­on), ther­eby avo­i­ding a fine. The com­pa­ny which pro­vi­ded the infor­ma­ti­on, as well as the other par­ti­ci­pa­ting alu­mi­num for­ging com­pa­nies, are evi­dent from the Noti­ce issued by the Fede­ral Car­tel Office.

Dama­ges for inju­red companies

Sin­ce such anti-competitive arran­ge­ments typi­cal­ly cau­se inju­ries, par­ti­cu­lar­ly to cus­to­mers of the par­ti­ci­pa­ting com­pa­nies, the inju­red par­ties are typi­cal­ly entit­led to dama­ge claims, as well as claims for desis­tance (§ 33a of the Act against Res­traints on Com­pe­ti­ti­on) (only in Ger­man). In this case, the affec­ted cus­to­mers con­sist in par­ti­cu­lar of manu­fac­tu­r­ers and sup­pli­ers in the auto­mo­ti­ve indus­try, the motor­cy­cle indus­try and other sec­tors. Accor­din­gly, the cus­to­mers of each of the­se com­pa­nies are advi­sed to clo­se­ly scru­ti­ni­ze rele­vant pro­jects which may have been exe­cu­ted in recent years. They can base their exami­na­ti­on on the Fede­ral Car­tel Office­’s case report, which is expec­ted in the coming days and weeks, and which will con­tain detail­ed infor­ma­ti­on about the case.

Fede­ral Car­tel Office­’s order not yet final and binding

As of the publi­ca­ti­on of this artic­le, the fines which have been impo­sed are not yet final and bin­ding. The par­ti­ci­pa­ting com­pa­nies have the opti­on of appe­al­ing the decis­i­on within one month, in which case the Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Dus­sel­dorf would rule on the appeal. At least one of the par­ti­ci­pa­ting com­pa­nies has alre­a­dy announ­ced that it would take steps in this direction.


Stay up-to-date

We use your email address exclusively for sending our newsletter. You have the right to revoke your consent at any time with effect for the future. For further information, please refer to our privacy policy.